Every four weeks, my liberal value system is tested when I visit my OB/GYN for my monthly prenatal appointment.
Women of every age and varying states of fertility sit on one side of the hushed, tasteful waiting room of this private practice. Older women, clearly in menopause, with short sleeves in the middle of February and neat, graying hair. Women like me, who may or may not be pregnant. Women who are simply there for a quick annual exam and a pap smear.
Then there is the other side.
Near the door to the surgical center.
Women with red-rimmed eyes. Women laughing nervously with a friend. Young women, clearly college students, with their mothers. Women still slender, dressed in jeans and trendy tops or big baggy sweatshirts.
These women are waiting for an abortion.
My doctor is, I believe, the only physician in my area who performs abortions, with the exception of Planned Parenthood.
I did not know this when I joined her practice, hearing only that she was the best in the area. Our crappy insurance allows me to get charged an arm and a leg by any doctor I wish, and so I wished to have the best.
The knowledge that she is also a well-known reproductive rights advocate would never have swayed my decision to enroll as a patient. In fact, I am pleased to know that there is a place for women in need, a place for women who made a painful decision and deserve an excellent physician to guide them through the process of terminating their pregnancy.
But.
Sitting on the opposite side of the room during my last appointment, the phone rang. The terribly rude and indiscrete receptionist loudly questioned the caller for all of us to hear.
“When was your last period?” Pause. “That makes you about six weeks.” Pause. “The surgery is outpatient. If you take the pill, that is something you can do at home.” Pause. “Four-hundred dollars.” Pause. “That is six hundred.”
With each staccato sentence, I felt my hand creep ever nearer my small belly. She booked an appointment for the caller, and as she hung up I found myself staring at her, mouth agape and palm pressed against my womb.
My gaze strayed to the other side of the room, where one woman sat, alone and looking anywhere but at me or the receptionist.
She has a baby in her belly, I thought. Like my baby.
My heart lurched a little.
Judge her I did not; I understand that every circumstance is different. I understand there are reasons – good ones, valid ones – that women terminate pregnancy. I cannot understand, but can certainly imagine, what an agonizing decision it must be to take such a step.
And I fully, with every fiber of my being, support the right of all women to have control over their bodies. Being free to make the right choice for you – no matter how personally painful it is for the woman or how difficult it is for someone else to understand – is a basic human right.
Should anyone or any institution threaten that right even slightly, I will stand up with my sisters and declare it fundamental. I will fight to maintain this right.
But.
I have never been confronted so intimately with the knowledge that in the waiting room, there is a baby. And later, there is not.
Being human, and, specifically, being a woman, is sometimes uncomfortable. Sometimes we have to look in the face of our beliefs, the personification of those beliefs in their living, breathing form, and we are forced to review our value systems and evaluate how we really feel about certain core issues.
This is a true test.
My values remain intact. And because I, too, am human and therefore flawed, so does my unease.



{ 3 trackbacks }
{ 66 comments… read them below or add one }
← Previous Comments
You rock star. This was so beautifully written and courageous!
This was a great post. And that last part about being uncomfortable was so true. We can’t always be comfortable with the things we believe in, but that doesn’t make it wrong.
I’m still glad we have a choice.
I think you’ve captured it so perfectly: the division within the room and within yourself. I feel the same tug of war in myself: You have the absolute right to choose, but it hurts my heart that you have to.
i share a lot of your feelings in this messy terrain. i am pro-choice, and yet i think abortion is also a sad thing for most. i adamantly want the option to remain an option, politically, but i am less and less personally comfortable with the way that option is sometimes taken up. only sometimes. but part of the issue of choice is always going to be that there are choices that we do not understand.
my own particular site of struggle with the topic is not at my OB office but close to home, with the repeat abortions chosen by two of my half-sibling’s partners. and it should be unrelated that i struggle to have live babies, but i am human, and it is not. i think we’ve failed, societally, to bring into being the better world that would make it easier for a woman or even a couple to openly own and take responsibility for reproductive desires and plans than to abort a consecutive number of times. and yet i see that happening in two separate places in my own family. and it blows my mind and leaves me raw, unable to reconcile my politics with my bafflement, my resentment.
this is a Pandora’s box, but i think it is one that is better open, talked about. a brave post.
Even for rape victims the morning after pill is a much better option than an abortion–yes there should be more awareness of this option for all women. What I’m saying is there are alternatives to abortion–whether or not it is a woman’s choice. A responsible choice should be made with sexual activity first and foremost. And in the cases of rape there is the morning after pill.
Medical complications to pregnancy should be the only case where abortion is allowed. All other cases are entirely preventable.
I really like how you capture the grey aspects of this issue. I come from the pro-life side — but when I think of the individual women making this decision, and the circumstances surrounding their choice, it makes me uncomfortable in the same way you described. And like you, I re-evaluate and reaffirm, and am uneasy.
Wow. I wouldn’t have touched this issue with a 10-foot-pole as I know how sticky it can be. You expressed everything so well. This is far from being a black and white issue. Thank you for illuminating the shades of gray. Oh and I just wrote a bunch of other abortion-related thoughts, but they came out all wrong, so I deleted them. See why I don’t write about this? Anyway, I’m pro-choice and you captured so perfectly how I feel. So thank you.
I know exactly what you mean. I wrote about how my feelings on the issue are now so conflicted, but not nearly as eloquently. Abortion was so much more … abstract … before having a baby. It is a very complicated subject.
oh, wow. good post, and good you for writing it. it is a strange thing how feelings change – and I had the realisations a couple of times during my pregnancy – even if the underlying belief doesn’t. while I can’t see myself in a place where I would choose abortion, I’m never about to deny anyone else (or my self that I can’t envision) and am utterly pro-choice.
But, yeah, the clinic needs a vastly different set up. Please tell us that your doc is open to suggestions??
Ahh. You know a good song for this post? Brick by Ben Folds Five. I was listening to it last night and the story he tells about his girlfriend’s abortion is just…
I understand. A couple of years ago one of my dearest friends got pregnant and ultimately had an abortion. I’m pro-choice, but it was very, very difficult knowing what she went through and what she decided, because I don’t think I would have made the same choice in her particular set of circumstances AND because, well, the issue gets a bit murky once you’re a mother.
I still would have gone with my friend and sat on the other side of the room holding her hand, but she insisted on going alone. I’m the only person who knew then, or now.
Hey – you know, I am so very glad you wrote this. One of the things I’ve been uneasy with in the wonderful world that is feminism is just the part of it where we can’t talk biology. So much feminism has done for me, but there is a very real sense I get, in perhaps the more academic circles of feminism I’ve haunted, that rejects talking about and coping with the female body in some real honest way. Thank you for your honesty.
It moved me today.
What a powerful and moving post. Beautifully written and brave. I’m glad I found your site!
It all seems like a consequence of a careless and thoughtless person.
It’s people pushing patently false ideas like this about women, their bodies, and their choices that make me more and more pro-choice every day.
Nice entry, Mrs. Chicken.
Very nice. We should be uneasy about making that choice. It should be one that is never made lightly. It should not be one made in lieu of responsible sexuality. But it must remain a choice, however uncomfortable.
What a beautiful post. I am adamantly pro choice but completely understand how awkward that must be. We had fertility issues before my first was born and clearly remember sitting in an office as a 15/16 year old girl bitched and complained about being pregnant and discussing with her friend various home grown abortiofacients (I kid you not, douching with comet was discussed at length). There is no easy way to make decisions like this. You have my utmost respect for writing this post.
← Previous Comments