Something silly happened at preschool this week.
In the grand scheme, it isn’t a big deal. But the sound of another girl taunting my daughter wounded me on all kinds of levels—the very least of which was that my mother-heart turned black and hateful, and it took every ounce of self-control I had to keep from shaking the other girl.
Watching my daughter’s face crumple into a sensitive, tearful mask of hurt feelings nearly undid me. It was the first time I’ve ever seen another child truly hurt her.
Sure, there have been spats over toys, but this was a wound cut open with mean words.
That is an animal of a different color.
The incident is over: discussed with parents, teachers and children alike, mine included. Lectures have been doled out and forgiveness extended, on all fronts.
We’re square, all of us. I’m not even one whit upset about the whole thing now.
***
I switched schools between my second- and third-grade years. I went from a large busing district to a neighborhood school in a walking district.
I remember my first day at the new school so clearly. My first bagged lunch, my first walk to the playground. The bike racks were loaded with Schwinn’s of all colors and kids teemed around the school yard like lemmings, yelling and fighting and laughing, all at once.
I was terrified.
An introvert even then—especially then—I hugged the red-brick walls, waiting desperately for the bell to ring and for a teacher to take over. I knew how to do the classroom, but recess overwhelmed me.
In we marched, and sat on a green square rug in a room that smelled of spoiled milk and too many bodies. The teacher took me by the shoulders, stood me in front of the group, and turned me around to face my classmates.
“This is our new student,” she said. “And you better watch out, because she is smarter than all of you.”
The girl who became the woman who has been my best friend for more than 25 years still tells this story when we get together for drinks.
She was in the front row, staring at me, just one set of 30 eyes trained on that hateful new student.
***
My freshman biology teacher liked me very much.
The feeling was mutual. She made the class feel more like the best study hall you ever had, and a lot less like a science course. We spent a lot of time making each other laugh.
One day, she came and sat next to me while my lab partner and I made disgusting jokes about the female grasshopper we were dissecting.
She giggled along with us, like a school-girl herself. I was wearing a red sweater with a deep V-neck, pilfered from my mother’s closet, and a swingy ponytail.
I turned my face to her, and she gave me the strangest smile.
“You,” she said, “are going to be a huge success. I just know it.”
***
They looked like money.
You can just tell when kids have money. It comes off them in waves. It isn’t just their clothes or pocketbooks. It’s an air of entitlement and confidence that only comes with parents who have fat and happy bank accounts.
I had a small-city mullet and my first pair of Guess? Jeans, resting uncomfortably on my slender 15-year-old hips. The denim was still stiff, purchased just the day before in a fit of parental desperation. My mother handed me the pants, a pleading look on her face.
It was our second week in London.
I walked into the lunch room with a tray, looking dazed. All around me kids at round tables laughed, the precocious sheen of years spent abroad giving them an aura of adulthood.
I stood there for just a moment, and abruptly turned on my heels.
I ate lunch in the stairwell for almost a year, until I was befriended by a ragtag group of kids who called themselves the Misfit Toys.
I knew in my heart I wasn’t supposed to be a misfit. I knew I was smart and funny and sophisticated. But so fearful! So afraid to open myself!
Terrified to take a chance. Terrified to be rejected.
***
When The Poo turned to me, that look on her face, it took me right back to those dark places inside me that chant a refrain of worthlessness. It is a sad song I’ve spent years and many, many dollars trying to silence. I do not know whose voice it is. I do know that it lives inside me, for better or worse.
It is the force that drives me. It is the voice that makes me stumble when I get too close to the light of true success.
It is the force that made me rage when a small girl said a mean thing to my daughter.
Raising a girl is a wonderful, dreadful responsiblity. It is often a joy. But some days, when the reflection back is just a little bit too familiar, it hurts me deep inside my soul.



{ 19 comments… read them below or add one }
well said Mrs. C, well said.
Oh, how these members can quickly be stoked to more. So tenuous this line between girl and woman, daughter and mom. You are so strong and beautiful.
Beautifully stated.
Been there. And having experienced it with all 3 of mine at different points along the way, I can honestly say that there is no pain like the pain you feel when you see your child is being hurt by another, and unfortunately, it doesn’t get easier when it happens again.
Oh, I know what you mean all too well on both fronts. Girls are so mean and we have dealt with it since my daughter was in Pre-3s. I don’t know what it is about girls that make them cut like a knife. I am looking forward to my son going to school, getting called that he was in a fight, only for him to say “It ain’t nothing, Mom, we are friends, again.” Girls the reason for therapy.
Oh this is so true and so painful. I have felt the same way. Motherhood, childhood – it’s all so hard.
Lovely post, Mrs. C.
it is no easier with boys, i hate to tell you. when your kid is about 3, you realize that you cannot protect them from the pain their peers will inflict.
Oh, my heart. I would have been your friend.
Wonderful post.
I have a question I think I will just email you
Great post! My oldest is only three and I still cringe when I look at him and think that he’ll have to deal with the cruel world and the little snots that live in it!
I share that pain. I prayed for boys when I was pregnant just because of that. Thank god my wish came true.
Kids are cruel. In fact, kids are horrible little shits sometimes, and the older they are, the worse it gets.
I remember so well the three years I spent tormented at my second primary school, told that I should fight my own battles, even when faced with physical harm and threats that no child should have to face – especially from another child. I remember the self-destructive behaviour it drove me to, my problems with self-injury began when I was 11, and it’s only recently, more than a decade since, that I’ve managed to shake that addiction – and that shakeage is dubious at best.
I see it every day on the playground of the preschool I teach at. I’m lucky: my age group is too young to really know how to wound someone deep down. Oh, they slap each other, sometimes they bite. But that’s only physical. It’s easily dealt with. But the older kids… the four-year-olds and up… oh, they’re beasts sometimes. They say things that make my heart shrivel.
I remember last year when Sasha told Michael (one of the sweetest, most sensitive 6-year-olds I’ve ever met) that he was Satan’s child and he would go to hell. I don’t know where she learned to say such things – though her family’s a member of Rhema church, so I guess it’s not surprising. I was so angry that day. She’s usually a bright, loving child… and I don’t think she even really meant anything by saying that. But Michael… he was so upset he told me he wanted to kill himself.
Having been a child suicidal at age 12, hearing those words out of the mouth of a preschooler tore me to shreds. I rounded on Sasha and actually belittled her to the point where she was reduced to tears. It’s one of my worst moments as a teacher – I handled that situation very badly. I cut that poor girl down and with every word from my mouth I watched her grow smaller inside.
Of course, that situation wasn’t her fault. It was the fault of parents who are stupid enough to buy into a cult-like evangelistic church and expose their children to preachings and sermons that teach them to hate.
Yet I still couldn’t help it. I saw a part of myself in Michael. A loner, smaller than the other children, often excluded from games, and branded a Satanist. I was 12 when that happened to me; he was half that age.
I’ve learned from that day though. I don’t allow myself to get emotionally drawn in, because it breeds only a vicious cycle that honestly is better wiped out. The only thing to do is accept that kids are cruel little shits at times. Every single one of them will hurt their friends even if they don’t mean to. Kids don’t have tact, they don’t have years of socialising to know when saying certain things is just not appropriate.
The only thing to teach the victims is to stand tall, tell them it’s not true. Teach them that they’re strong, and good, and beautiful, and nothing anyone ever says will change that.
Oh, how I wonder, when I watch my daughter interact with her preschool mates, if I was the same? Or is she more out going than me?
It is strange, having this little mirror in which to rehash all of that stuff. I don’t do this with my boys.
If I had your talent for writing….
Wow. This is a brilliant post.
Isn’t it amazing how certain things trigger those old memories?
It happens to me quite often.
I have felt that way so many times and I dread the day that someone makes my daughter feel like that. I wish I could absorb all the hurt she will ever face but I know that is not possible.
Oh, oh, oh. I love having a little girl, but am so very afraid of this same thing. The words you spoke are very close to my own heart.
There is so much emotional scarring from my past, I’m amazed I can even talk to people anymore. Kids are cruel.
And I’m a little thankful at times that Cordy can’t tell when someone is mean to her. She doesn’t understand and so she is spared the sting. I’m not sure how long it will last, but it has kept me from unleashing a string of hate on another kid.
I nearly turned into GORT the other day too. Scared myself actually.
Your teacher was right, I think. You are going to be a huge success–take one look at the girl you’re raising.
And you’ve certainly learned how to open yourself up now, even it means using a keyboard. Think how much that means to so many. Go get ‘em, Mrs. Chicken. Lead the way.
I also had my share of bad experiences at school. How I wish I could shield my daughter from this kind of pain, and I also don’t know how I would react if I could witness any incident.